Not Totoro

What was suppose to be Totoro nails ended up looking like some sort of grey animal. A cat? A seal? Maybe even an owl? 

Pinky and thumb have 2 coats of Maybelline Color Show Impeccable Greys.
Ring has 2 coats of Maybelline Color Show Impeccable Greys. Taped off and applied 2 coats of Maybelline Color Show Audacious Asphalt.
Totoro/cat/seal/owl has 3 coats of Audacious Asphalt. It's tummy has 2 coats of Essie Marshmallow. Eyes are 2 dots of Essie Blanc and topped with Essie Licorice. Whiskers and tummy fur is Essie Licorice. 

Totoro nails?

Seal? Cat? Owl?

Maybelline Color Show : Audacious Asphalt
Maybelline Color Show : Impeccable Greys
Essie : Marshmallow
Essie : Licorice
Essie : Blanc